Want to learn more about our services? Book a 15-minute consultation with our team today!

Health and Welfare Plan Audits: When You Need One

HR manager reviewing health and welfare benefit plan documents at a desk

A health and welfare plan audit is generally required only when the plan covers 100 or more participants at the beginning of the plan year and holds assets in a trust, making it a “funded” large plan under ERISA. If the plan pays benefits directly from the employer’s general assets or entirely through insurance contracts, it is usually exempt from the independent audit even when it covers more than 100 participants. The participant count and the plan’s funding status are the two tests that decide whether you must attach audited financial statements to your Form 5500.

Many plan sponsors assume the rules that govern their 401(k) plan apply equally to their medical, dental, and disability benefits. They do not. Welfare plans follow a different path because of how they are funded and reported, and that difference is where sponsors most often get the audit question wrong. This article walks through when a health and welfare plan audit is triggered, when it is not, and how to confirm your obligation before filing.

What a Health and Welfare Plan Is Under ERISA

A welfare benefit plan is any plan, fund, or program an employer maintains to provide benefits such as medical, dental, vision, life insurance, disability, severance, or similar coverage to employees. The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, known as ERISA, governs most of these plans in the private sector. ERISA sets the reporting, disclosure, and fiduciary standards that determine, among other things, whether an annual audit is necessary.

Welfare plans differ from retirement plans in a fundamental way. A retirement plan holds and invests participant money for future payout, while most welfare plans pay current-year claims as they come due. That structural difference drives the different audit treatment, because the audit requirement is tied closely to whether plan assets are being held and managed over time.

Employers often administer several welfare benefits under a single “wrap” plan document or as separate plans. How the benefits are grouped affects the participant count and therefore the filing and audit analysis. Getting the plan structure right on paper is the first step before any audit determination can be made.

The 100-Participant Threshold and How to Count

ERISA draws the line between a “small” plan and a “large” plan at 100 participants, measured as of the beginning of the plan year. A plan with fewer than 100 participants at the start of the year is a small plan, and a plan with 100 or more is a large plan. Only large plans are candidates for the annual audit requirement, and even then only when the funding test below is also met.

For a welfare plan, participants generally include employees currently covered by the plan and certain former employees, such as those on COBRA continuation coverage or retirees who remain eligible for benefits. Covered employees who have not yet enrolled but are eligible may also count, depending on the benefit. Counting dependents is not the standard; the participant figure is driven by the employee-level count, which is why a plan covering far fewer than 100 employees rarely crosses the threshold even if hundreds of family members receive coverage.

A transition rule sometimes called the 80-120 rule gives filers flexibility near the threshold, allowing a plan with between 80 and 120 participants at the beginning of the year to file in the same category it used the prior year. This rule is widely applied to retirement plans to smooth out small year-to-year swings. For welfare plans, however, the funding question usually settles the audit answer well before the 80-120 rule matters, so sponsors should not lean on it as an audit-avoidance tool. Confirm the exact count method against the current Form 5500 instructions each year, because the counting rules and the form itself are periodically revised.

The Funding Test: Why Most Welfare Plans Escape the Audit

Here is the distinction that separates welfare plans from retirement plans. Even a large welfare plan with well over 100 participants does not automatically need an audit. The plan must also be “funded,” meaning it holds assets in a trust or otherwise sets aside participant contributions apart from the employer’s general assets. A voluntary employees’ beneficiary association, or VEBA trust, is a common example of a funded arrangement.

The U.S. Department of Labor provides a limited exemption and alternative method of compliance for unfunded plans and for certain insured plans. Under 29 CFR 2520.104-44, a welfare plan that is unfunded, fully insured, or a combination of the two generally does not have to engage an independent qualified public accountant, even if it covers 100 or more participants. An unfunded plan pays benefits directly from the employer’s general assets, and a fully insured plan pays benefits through insurance contracts with premiums drawn from general assets or partly from participant contributions handled within the regulation’s limits.

In practical terms, the majority of employer medical, dental, and disability plans are either self-funded from general assets or fully insured, and those plans file Form 5500 without an audit. The audit obligation surfaces when a sponsor funds the plan through a trust and the participant count reaches 100 or more. If you are unsure whether your plan is funded, examine whether a trust exists, whether a separate bank or investment account holds plan assets, and how participant contributions flow. Those facts, not the benefit type, determine the outcome.

Form 5500 Reporting and the Role of the Audit

Form 5500 is the annual return that most ERISA welfare plans with 100 or more participants must file with the Department of Labor, the IRS, and the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation through the EFAST2 system. Small unfunded, insured, or combination welfare plans are often exempt from filing altogether, which is another reason the audit question so rarely reaches small employers. The Department of Labor’s overview of the Form 5500 series explains the electronic filing framework and the schedules that accompany the return.

When a large funded welfare plan does require an audit, the plan must attach the report of an independent qualified public accountant to the Form 5500. The accountant examines the plan’s financial statements and supporting schedules, tests contributions and benefit payments, and evaluates internal controls over plan operations. The report expresses an opinion on whether the financial statements are presented fairly in accordance with the applicable accounting framework.

Insured welfare plans that would otherwise qualify for the limited exemption but happen to cover 100 or more participants still file Form 5500 and typically attach Schedule A to report insurance contract information. They do not attach an accountant’s report. Reviewing which schedules apply to your specific plan is essential, because the schedules required often signal whether an audit is in play.

Common Scenarios Sponsors Encounter

A company with 400 employees enrolled in a fully insured group medical plan files Form 5500 but needs no audit, because the plan is insured rather than funded through a trust. The same company would need an audit if it moved those benefits into a VEBA trust and kept the participant count above 100. The single change that flips the requirement is the funding mechanism, not the number of employees.

A self-insured health plan that pays claims from the employer’s general operating account is treated as unfunded and generally avoids the audit even with thousands of covered employees. If that same plan begins collecting employee contributions and holding them in a segregated trust, it can become a funded plan subject to audit once it is large. Sponsors who make benefit-funding changes mid-stream should revisit the audit analysis promptly rather than wait until filing season.

Multiple employer welfare arrangements and plans with their own trusts deserve particular attention, because the trust itself usually establishes funded status. In these cases the audit is often required, and the engagement should be planned early so financial statements are ready when the Form 5500 is due. Early planning also gives the plan time to gather participant data, contribution records, and claims information the auditor will request.

How to Confirm Your Audit Obligation

Start by fixing the plan year and pulling an accurate participant count as of the first day of that year, using the ERISA participant definition rather than a raw headcount of covered lives. Then determine the funding mechanism by confirming whether a trust holds any plan assets and how participant contributions are handled. Those two facts resolve the audit question for the large majority of welfare plans.

If the plan is large and funded, engage an independent qualified public accountant with employee benefit plan experience well before the Form 5500 deadline, which generally falls seven months after the plan year ends, with an available extension. The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants maintains resources and standards for these engagements through its Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center, and selecting a firm experienced in ERISA audits reduces the risk of deficiencies that draw Department of Labor scrutiny. A quality audit protects the plan’s fiduciaries as much as it satisfies the filing requirement.

Because the rules carry real penalties for late or deficient filings, sponsors who are uncertain should document their analysis and seek professional guidance rather than guess. The cost of a reasoned determination is far lower than the cost of a rejected filing or an enforcement action. If your organization sponsors welfare benefits and you are unsure where you stand, a focused review of plan structure and funding is the fastest way to get clarity.

Pease Bell advises plan sponsors on the full ERISA reporting picture, from determining whether an audit applies to performing the engagement itself. Explore our audit and assurance services to see how we approach employee benefit plan work, and review our accounting services for related compliance and advisory support. Getting the health and welfare plan audit question right starts with the two tests above, and we can help you apply them to your specific plan.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a fully insured health plan need an audit?

Generally no. Under 29 CFR 2520.104-44, a welfare plan that is unfunded, fully insured, or a combination of the two generally does not have to engage an independent qualified public accountant, even if it covers 100 or more participants. A large insured plan still files Form 5500 and typically attaches Schedule A, but it does not attach an accountant’s report.

Does a VEBA trust trigger a health and welfare plan audit?

A VEBA trust is a common example of a funded welfare arrangement, because it holds assets apart from the employer’s general assets. If a plan funded through a trust has 100 or more participants at the beginning of the plan year, it generally must attach an independent auditor’s report to its Form 5500.

Do dependents count toward the 100-participant threshold for a welfare plan?

Counting dependents is not the standard. The participant figure is driven by the employee-level count, including currently covered employees and certain former employees, such as those on COBRA continuation coverage or retirees who remain eligible. Eligible employees who have not enrolled may also count, depending on the benefit. A plan covering far fewer than 100 employees rarely crosses the threshold.

Does a self-insured health plan need an independent audit?

A self-insured health plan that pays claims from the employer’s general operating account is treated as unfunded and generally avoids the audit, even with thousands of covered employees. If that plan begins collecting employee contributions and holding them in a segregated trust, it can become a funded plan subject to audit once it is large.

What should I check to tell whether my welfare plan is funded?

Examine whether a trust exists, whether a separate bank or investment account holds plan assets, and how participant contributions flow. Those facts, not the benefit type, determine whether the plan is funded. Combined with an accurate participant count as of the first day of the plan year, they resolve the audit question for the large majority of welfare plans.

Let’s talk about your business.