A defined benefit plan audit is an independent examination of a pension plan’s financial statements that must be attached to the plan’s Form 5500 once the plan is classified as a large plan. For most plans, that classification is triggered when the plan has 100 or more participants at the beginning of the plan year, subject to a transition rule for plans near the threshold. The audit differs from a 401(k) audit because it depends heavily on actuarial work, the valuation of plan liabilities, and funding information reported on Schedule SB or Schedule MB.
Sponsors of pension plans often underestimate how much the actuary, the auditor, and the plan administrator must coordinate to complete a clean filing on time. This guide explains the audit triggers, the role of the actuary, how plan assets and benefit obligations are examined, and what changed under the current reporting standard. It is written for plan sponsors, HR leaders, and finance teams who want to understand their responsibilities before the audit begins.
When a Defined Benefit Plan Audit Is Required
The audit requirement is driven by participant count, not by plan assets or contribution levels. A pension plan generally becomes a large plan, and therefore subject to audit, when it covers 100 or more participants as measured at the beginning of the plan year. For a defined benefit plan, the participant count includes active employees accruing benefits, retirees and beneficiaries receiving payments, and separated participants with vested rights that have not been paid out.
A common point of confusion is the so-called 80-120 participant rule. Under this transition rule, a plan with between 80 and 120 participants at the beginning of the plan year may file in the same category it used the prior year. In practice, a plan that filed as a small plan last year can continue filing as a small plan, and avoid the audit, until its participant count exceeds 120. The U.S. Department of Labor explains the Form 5500 series and its filing categories in detail on its Form 5500 Series page.
Because defined benefit plans frequently retain terminated vested participants on their rolls for years, the count tends to drift upward even when active headcount is flat. Sponsors should track the beginning-of-year count every year rather than assuming last year’s status carries forward. Crossing the threshold creates an audit obligation with a firm deadline, and engaging an auditor late is one of the most common causes of a missed or extended filing.
Actuarial Coordination and Schedule SB
The actuary is central to a defined benefit plan audit in a way that has no parallel in a defined contribution audit. A single-employer defined benefit plan reports its funding information on Schedule SB, while a multiemployer plan reports comparable information on Schedule MB. Both schedules are attachments to the Form 5500 and are signed by the plan’s enrolled actuary, who is approved by the Joint Board for the Enrollment of Actuaries.
Schedule SB reports the plan’s funding target, the actuarial value of plan assets, the actuarial assumptions used, the plan’s normal cost, and the minimum required contribution for the year. The Department of Labor publishes the official form and instructions for the Schedule SB single-employer actuarial information. By signing the schedule, the enrolled actuary certifies that the information is complete and accurate based on the plan provisions and the data supplied.
During the audit, the auditor uses the actuary’s work as a specialist’s input rather than re-performing the valuation. The auditor evaluates whether the actuary is competent and objective, tests the census data the sponsor provided to the actuary, and assesses whether the actuarial assumptions and methods are reasonable in the context of the financial statements. One of the auditor’s defined responsibilities is to confirm that contributions satisfy the minimum funding requirements, which involves reviewing Schedule SB or Schedule MB.
This means the quality of the audit depends on the quality of the census data long before the auditor arrives. Errors in dates of birth, hire dates, compensation history, or termination dates flow through the actuarial valuation and distort the benefit obligation. Sponsors who reconcile payroll and HR records to the data sent to the actuary each year tend to experience far smoother audits.
Valuing Plan Assets and Benefit Obligations
A defined benefit plan audit examines two very different sides of the plan. On the asset side, the auditor tests the existence, ownership, and valuation of plan investments, which may include pooled funds, insurance contracts, separately managed accounts, and in some cases alternative investments. On the obligation side, the auditor focuses on the actuarially determined benefit liability and the related disclosures in the financial statements.
Hard-to-value investments deserve particular attention. Investments without a readily determinable fair value, such as certain private funds or group annuity contracts, require additional evidence and more extensive disclosure. Sponsors should confirm early that the custodian and investment managers can provide audit-ready valuations and the supporting documentation the auditor will request.
The benefit obligation is where the actuarial work and the financial statements meet. The financial statements present the actuarial present value of accumulated plan benefits and the changes in that value during the year, and these figures rest on the actuary’s assumptions about interest rates, mortality, retirement age, and salary growth where applicable. Because small changes in the discount rate can move the obligation significantly, the auditor pays close attention to how assumptions were selected and whether they are applied consistently.
Sponsors should also distinguish Form 5500 reporting from Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation obligations. PBGC premium filings are separate from the Form 5500, but they draw on the same funding and participant data, so inconsistencies between the two can surface during the audit. The PBGC describes its role in insuring private pension benefits on its How PBGC Operates page.
What Changed Under SAS 136
The audit standard that governs these engagements changed meaningfully in recent years. Statement on Auditing Standards No. 136, codified as AU-C section 703 in the AICPA Professional Standards, is effective for plan financial statements for periods ending on or after December 15, 2021. The standard reshaped both the auditor’s report and the sponsor’s documented responsibilities.
The most visible change is the treatment of what used to be called the limited-scope audit. Under SAS 136, that engagement is now the ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit. When a qualified institution certifies the completeness and accuracy of the investment information, the auditor can rely on that certification for the certified investments, but the auditor now issues an opinion on the rest of the financial statements rather than disclaiming an opinion on the whole. The AICPA summarizes the framework for employee benefit plan audits through its Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center.
SAS 136 also formalized the plan sponsor’s responsibilities. The sponsor must acknowledge responsibility for maintaining a current plan instrument, administering the plan in accordance with its terms, and determining whether an ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit is permissible. The sponsor must also provide a substantially complete draft Form 5500 to the auditor before the audit report is dated, which has made the timing of the actuary’s Schedule SB work more important than ever.
For defined benefit plans specifically, these requirements raise the stakes on coordination. The actuary must finalize the valuation and Schedule SB, the sponsor must assemble the draft Form 5500, and the auditor must complete procedures over both the certified investments and the actuarially driven obligation before signing. Plans that sequence this work early in the cycle avoid the compression that leads to rushed reviews near the filing deadline.
How Sponsors Can Prepare for a Smooth Audit
Preparation starts with the data. Reconciling the participant census, payroll records, and benefit payment history to the information supplied to the actuary removes one of the largest sources of audit friction. Sponsors should also gather the signed plan document and all amendments, the trust or custodial statements, the investment certifications where applicable, and the prior year’s Form 5500 and audit report.
Engaging the audit firm well before the filing deadline gives everyone room to resolve questions about valuation, assumptions, or unusual transactions. It also lets the auditor coordinate directly with the actuary and the custodian rather than routing every request through plan staff. Early engagement is especially valuable in a year when the plan is crossing the large plan threshold for the first time or has undergone a freeze, a plan termination, or a risk transfer such as an annuity purchase.
Sponsors who treat the audit as an annual compliance project rather than a scramble generally see lower fees, fewer adjustments, and cleaner filings. A defined benefit plan audit is demanding because it sits at the intersection of investment accounting, actuarial science, and ERISA compliance, but each of those pieces becomes manageable when the responsible parties coordinate on a realistic timeline.
Pease Bell works with plan sponsors across the full audit cycle, from evaluating whether a plan has crossed the audit threshold to coordinating with actuaries and custodians through the final report. To understand how a plan audit fits within a broader assurance engagement, review our audit and assurance services and our overview of accounting services. Sponsors who prepare early and keep their census data clean position the plan for a timely, defensible Form 5500 filing every year.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who counts as a participant in a defined benefit plan for audit purposes?
For a defined benefit plan, the participant count includes active employees accruing benefits, retirees and beneficiaries receiving payments, and separated participants with vested rights that have not been paid out. Because terminated vested participants often stay on the rolls for years, the count can drift upward even when active headcount is flat, so track the beginning-of-year count annually.
How does the 80-120 rule apply to a defined benefit plan audit?
Under the 80-120 transition rule, a plan with between 80 and 120 participants at the beginning of the plan year may file in the same category it used the prior year. A defined benefit plan that filed as a small plan last year can continue filing as a small plan, and avoid the audit, until its participant count exceeds 120.
Does the auditor re-perform the actuarial valuation?
No. The auditor uses the actuary’s work as a specialist’s input rather than re-performing the valuation. The auditor evaluates whether the actuary is competent and objective, tests the census data the sponsor provided to the actuary, assesses whether assumptions and methods are reasonable, and confirms contributions satisfy minimum funding requirements by reviewing Schedule SB or Schedule MB.
What information does Schedule SB report?
Schedule SB reports a single-employer defined benefit plan’s funding target, the actuarial value of plan assets, the actuarial assumptions used, the plan’s normal cost, and the minimum required contribution for the year. It is attached to the Form 5500 and signed by the plan’s enrolled actuary, who certifies that the information is complete and accurate based on plan provisions and data supplied.
What must a plan sponsor provide to the auditor under SAS 136?
Under SAS 136, the sponsor must acknowledge responsibility for maintaining a current plan instrument, administering the plan in accordance with its terms, and determining whether an ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit is permissible. The sponsor must also provide a substantially complete draft Form 5500 before the audit report is dated, which makes the timing of the actuary’s Schedule SB work more important.
Are PBGC premium filings part of the Form 5500?
No. PBGC premium filings are separate from the Form 5500, but they draw on the same funding and participant data. Because of that overlap, inconsistencies between the PBGC filings and the Form 5500 can surface during the defined benefit plan audit, so sponsors should keep the underlying data consistent across both.




